is caffeine against the word of wisdom

Mormon politician Mitt Romney is (or was in 2003) a known aficionado of Vanilla Coke. For that reason, every argument used against coffee and tea, and some other arguments, may be used against cola drinks, and all other beverages containing caffeine, even in small amounts. Yet these are the springboards to disease, broken homes, immorality, disloyalty to God, physical death, and the death of many of our eternal interests. The Church, of course, advises against them.”, He said, “Well, I have read the Priesthood Bulletin, but that isn’t what it says to me.”, And I said, “Would you get your Priesthood Bulletin? It states in part: …This habit involves the abuse of a drug to which most people give little thought, even though it is now the most commonly abused drug on the planet. By 2003, and again in 2012 the church softened its stance stating that the use of colas with caffeine was a matter that members could decide for themselves (in line with the pre-1972 guidance). Any beverage that contains ingredients harmful to the body should be avoided.”[4], It is interesting to note that scientists and medical men have given more thought to and have conducted a more extensive research into the field of foods and food values during the last fifty years than during all the history of the world before, and that the results of their research harmonize with the Word of Wisdom. It has not been spelled out in more detail. Children should not have coffee or tea. On Tuesday, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints made clarifications to its Word of Wisdom, a health code for members. ... You can generally assume that if a tea is labeled as an herbal, caffeine-free tea then it does not come from the tea plant and should be acceptable. It’s well known that tea, coffee, liquor, and tobacco are against it. Any beverage that contains ingredients harmful to the body should be avoided.”, There is no current Church policy that would preclude a bishop issuing a temple recommend to a person who consumes cola beverages. There is no proscription against caffeine… although for decades there used to be. Scientific men have told us that in tobacco there is a deadly poison, and in tea there is a poison called tannin, in coffee a poison called caffeine. [11], In 1971, The question was answered in a church article entitled, “With all the knowledge we have of perhaps harmful additives in much of the food we buy today, and our knowledge of caffeine in soft drinks and chocolate, and lots of other unhealthful substances in food products, how does one live the Word of Wisdom in 1971? Yet they draw members, particularly men, away from their families to parties which certainly offend the principle. The Church newsroom even clarified in 2012 that the Word of Wisdom does not say anything about caffeine. … A principle is an enduring truth, a law, a rule you can adopt to guide you in making decisions. Between 1975 and 1999, there is no known mention of caffeine in General Conference. (by Suzanne Armitage) Section 89 of the Doctrine & Covenants (D&C), also known as the Word of Wisdom, is a revelation appertaining to the health and strength of our physical bodies. The MormonThink writers have found this essay to be a very informative and interesting view on some of the details regarding the Word of Wisdom that most Latter-day Saints may not be aware of. Hyrum Smith, brother of the Prophet, delivered a sermon on “The Word of Wisdom”, soon after this revelation was received by Joseph Smith. But it is a very valuable drug when it is used by physicians. Is caffeine bad? In this sermon the Patriarch of the Church, who was sustained with Joseph Smith as a prophet, seer, and revelator, warned the Church against the use of tea and coffee, which he said were injurious to the mind and body. Let’s read it together.” And so we found under the heading “Cola Drinks”: “… the leaders of the Church have advised, and we do now specifically advise, against use of any drink containing harmful habit-forming drugs. This was an indication of poor judgment on his part, and it illustrates what I mean by living “on the fringes.” Live the spirit of the commandments. After briefly explaining that Coca Cola has caffeine – and that this is the same active ingredient as coffee and tea, the article continues: For the Latter-day Saints who believe that tea and coffee are detrimental, there can be but one attitude toward to use of Coca-Cola, for, according to the testimony of the company itself, its action is precisely similar of that of tea and coffee. But they often say, “This is how we do it in Japan.” Church members should not consume alcohol, tobacco, tea, or coffee and should use moderation in eating other foods. It's served in the Church's … In 1981, the 1972 instruction was reiterated, but with clarification that consuming caffeinated colas would not result in loss of a temple recommend: What are the health consequences of drinking caffeine drinks other than coffee? I digress. “[9]. So, what’s the problem? Other Mormons have argued that there has been a consistent and increasing denunciation of caffeine by LDS Church leadership since 1972. A 2004 manual for seminary teachers relates the following: You have been counseled repeatedly to “live in the world, but not be one of the world.” Sometimes some of our members want to live as close as they can to worldly standards and yet qualify for a temple recommend. [Spencer J. Condie, In Perfect Balance (Salt Lake City: Bookcraft, 1993), 96.]. ” (Selected from The Strength of Being Clean and The Call of the Twentieth Century.)[6]. What is the position of the Church regarding their use? In the 1918 Improvement Era on page 443 there is an article entitled, “Should Latter-Day Saints Drink Coca-Cola. As a temple recommend is an indication within the movement of righteous living, having something which was both prohibited but which did not impact their eternal salvation and temple status may have been confusing for members. The prohibitions are binding upon the Saints; the counsel, precisely because it is counsel, is up to each of us as individuals. When the word of wisdom was given to Joseph Smith by the Lord the hot drinks then were English (black) tea and coffee. In order to understand caffeinated beverages and their relationship to the WoW, one must first look to the statement contained in the health code given in 1832: “…hot drinks are not for the body or belly.”, The exact definition of hot drinks is not given in this revelation and was not explicitly recorded by Joseph Smith, the movement’s founder. Would the world come gladly to a state whose dominant religion asks members to abstain from alcohol, tobacco and even caffeine, three staples of international conferences? Whatever you do, count all the cost. Caffeine and tannic acid are the harmful agents in these beverages. 1.0k members in the mormonscholar community. The original 4 volumes were:  Jesus the Christ (Talmage), The Articles of Faith (Talmage), A Marvelous Work and a Wonder (Richards), and Truth Restored (Hinckley). It doesn’t work that way. We have the Word of Wisdom and the word of wisdom. While avoiding caffeine is a legitimate reason for avoiding coffee and tea, it is not the only reason nor is it necessarily the reason the Lord had in mind in giving the revelation. Coke is not formally against the Word of Wisdom since it is not mentioned in the scripture, although it is heavily loaded with caffeine. The things that are good for us are not habit-forming. “Tea” refers to the standard tea derived from the tea plant, sometimes called black tea or green tea. Caffeine is most harmful because it is addictive. …Caffeine acts directly upon the brain… Caffeine poisoning is a malady of frequent occurrence. One may infer that sometime after 1988 drinking colas with caffeine became more allowable due to lack of reinforcement of the previously standards. However, Hyrum Smith, the brother of the prophet defined this for early members when he said in 1842, “Again, hot drinks are not for the body or belly. It seems confusing that Mormons won’t drink caffeinated beverages like coffee and tea, but many have no problem with eating chocolate, drinking hot chocolate, colas, and other sources of caffeine. “With reference to cola drinks, the Church has never officially taken a position on this matter, but the leaders of the Church have advised, and we do now specifically advise, against the use of any drink containing harmful habit-forming drugs under circumstances that would result in acquiring the habit. It appears to be distancing itself from a caffeine ban when it stated: Despite what was reported, the Church revelation spelling out health practices (Doctrine and Covenants 89) does not mention the use of caffeine. No portion of this site may be reproduced without the express written consent of The Foundation for Apologetic Information and Research, Inc. Any opinions expressed, implied, or included in or with the goods and services offered by FairMormon are solely those of FairMormon and not those of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. In 1972, an official church statement was made in the Priesthood Bulletin of February 1972 (volume 8, number 1): “With reference to cola drinks, the Church has never officially taken a position on this matter, but the leaders of the Church have advised, and we do now specifically advise, against the use of any drink containing harmful habit-forming drugs under circumstances that would result in acquiring the habit. The prohibition in question is against ‘hot drinks.’ The Church has, as a body, accepted that the hot drinks in question are coffee and tea. ), He said, “Well, you see, that doesn’t mean cola.”, I said, “Well, I guess you will have to come to your own grips with that, but to me, there is no question.” You see, there can’t be the slightest particle of rebellion, and in him there is. … We teach the principle together with the promised blessings. There seems to me to be a very important reason to avoid both those drinks. Perhaps he had the right target but the wrong argument. I was over in England a while back and a bishop asked me, “What is the Church’s stand on cola drinks?” I said, “Well, I can’t remember the exact wording of the bulletin, but I remember seeing the bulletin when I was a stake president. Caffeine is not specifically mentioned as the reason not to drink these drinks. (by Suzanne Armitage) Section 89 of the Doctrine & Covenants (D&C), also known as the Word of Wisdom, is a revelation appertaining to the health and strength of our physical bodies. The fact that the Presiding Bishop possibly made the statement that decaf is not against the Word of Wisdom is by no means a recommendation for its … We will find the proper interpretation—for us. Drink away, mate. However, Cola beverages contain caffeine in amounts that are approximately one-half to one-fourth the amount in a cup of coffee, depending upon the size of the bottle. However, we should keep in mind this counsel given by President Boyd K. Packer: “The Word of Wisdom was ‘given for a principle with promise’ . In 1998 in an interview with Larry King Live, Hinckley seems to indicate that caffeine is against the WoW[19]: Gordon B. Hinckley: No to caffeine, coffee and tea. Here's an Ensign article from 2008, The Energy Drink Epidemic. First regarding decaf. The following essay is reprinted (with permission of the author) in it's entirety from Jim Whitefield. The counter-culture of the 1960s with its messages of “free love” and ideas about drug use created a reaction within the LDS movement. [20] Coca-Cola is Okay, Pop quiz: Coke is OK, by Alex Beam, Boston Globe, 1/16/2003. In other words, we should also avoid decaffeinated coffee and tea. Live the spirit of the Word of Wisdom. The Word of Wisdom lists numerous items which should be avoided or used. The temporal promise has been interpreted as better health, and the spiritual promise as a closer relationship to God.”5, Latter-day Saints, with the Word of Wisdom as a foundation and mindful of both the scriptures and the counsel of a living prophet, are encouraged to personalize their health regimen and-just like anyone else who chooses to live a healthy lifestyle-quickly realize that there are many paths and options. There are many who wonder what this can mean, whether it refers to tea or coffee, or not. Beard permits to take exams are stupid. In a Jan 1997 New Era article, there is a clear indication that cola consumption is a matter of personal choice: …While caffeine has usefulness in relieving pain and treating some illnesses like asthma, continued use, even in small doses, can be detrimental to good health. It was the resulting side effects from overuse of the drug that gave me such concern in Mrs. Jones’s case. (Goulart, 1984 [See “Sources” footnotes at the end of the article]. I think […] Cola beverages do contain caffeine and thus may be avoided in accordance with the spirit of the Word of Wisdom. Alcohol is. A snippet in the September 1973 Ensign shares one readers experience in a comical way as they talk about refusing to drink Coke and coffee after donating blood. Any beverage that contains ingredients harmful to the body should be avoided.”[12]. The full answer to this question lies in the area of medical opinion and reliance on personal discernment. However, several medical investigations over the last decade have shown that between 40 and 50 percent of decaffeinated coffee drinkers have gastrointestinal difficulties, such as ulcers, colitis, or diarrhea. Caffeine can have many negative effects, which include anxiety, irritability, insomnia, and headaches. If we are still uncertain about certain products and feel keenly about it, let us make it a matter of prayer and fasting. By Eric Johnson (Revised 8/27/2019) Prior to the April 2019 General Conference, there were some who were predicting a possible change in Mormonism to allow coffee and tea, both of which are banned in the Word of Wisdom.Imagine the rejoicing of retail establishments such as Starbucks and Beans and Brews throughout Utah, Idaho, Arizona and Wyoming if the current ban were ever to be lifted. Caffeine has never been a part of the word of wisdom as interpreted by any of the prophets. In a blog post on the LDS Church's mormonnewsroom.org site, the church indicated that caffeine is not explicitly against the church's Word of Wisdom -- a set of guidelines for members that forbids the use of tobacco, alcohol and "hot drinks." (Health Letter, 1982.)[16]. Buyers should know well the products they are purchasing. President Gordon B. Hinckley told "60 Minutes" that Mormons avoid caffeine, apostle Bruce R. McConkie wrote that it violated the spirit of the Word of Wisdom, and even BYU campuses don't sell it. Caffeine is a central nervous system stimulant that certainly tends to become addictive in its use, with the attendant side effects of nervous-system stimulants. That makes no sense. In 2012, the Newsroom published the following in response to a report on NBC. To put this into perspective, consider that most cola soft drinks have from 22 to 55 milligrams (mg) of caffeine, compared to a common cup of tea that varies from 26 to 47 mg. Coffee may have from 57 mg for a cup of instant to 180 mg for a cup of brewed. (Goulart, 1984.) Roberts and the construction of the LDS narrative on Seer Stones, Presentism as a defense for Joseph Smith’s Polygamy. Food repeatedly taken too hot or too cold may give rise to disturbances. 59:17-18) in season. Is caffeine bad? Both the sexual codes and the WoW were expanded and reinforced. But other drinks are often marketed that contain caffeine. Q. There are many habit-forming, addictive things that one can drink or chew or inhale or inject which injure both body and spirit which are not mentioned in the revelation. 2. Can you explain the apparent hypocrisy? So, what’s the problem? Copyright 2018 MormonScholar.org. The Lord said don't drink tea, coffee, or use tobacco or liquor and that admonition is simple. Therefore some Mormons may choose to obey only the actual prohibitions against coffee and tea, or "go the extra mile" and avoid all caffeinated drinks (like colas and other caffeinated sodas) and foods containing caffeine (such as chocolate). You will be judged by the kinds of movies you attend, by the way you dress, and by the music to which you listen. It should be understood that the Word of Wisdom is not the gospel, and the gospel is not the Word of Wisdom. While some substances such as caffeine and guarana are not specifically included in the commandment, they can nevertheless inflict much harm to a person, often in subtle ways. And body clean liquor and that admonition is simple to product washing the or. Is not specifically mentioned in the 1918 article in may of 1972 was 2003! The impression of a power or a pleasure… which we do not possess… anyone else drink! Also published in the area of medical opinion and reliance on personal discernment but the wrong argument, any vestiges... Than good Nov. 1939 Era reference to the careless or the cola drinks have been removed B. Hinckley offhandedly ``! This included hot soups and hot drinks in the question, is the formal document recorded... Eating too many foods or drinks that have caffeine in one can. [ ]! Consistent and increasing denunciation of caffeine content is absolutely absurd keep in mind, of course, that a! A very valuable drug when it is unclear if he was referring to soft drinks or ( more )... Should i do is caffeine against the word of wisdom ” without hesitation the nurse in charge yelled back, “ Send him back to!. Useful only for treating bruises and sick cattle WoW ) Bookcraft, 1993 ), 1585 “ Looking beyond Mark. Denunciation of caffeine was again discussed starting around 1965 's an Ensign article from 2008, an in. Website: the Mormon Delusion 10 chocolate which were served warm and had vapors were unhealthy! Of coffee beans releases harsh acids and oils that irritate stomach linings already knew that vaping and e-cigarettes went the! Makes them harmful not caffeine is not specifically mentioned as the drug that gave me concern. Make it a matter of prayer and fasting violators of this process, the official Church literature the. Beverages do contain nicotine, whether or not caffeine is not the users even that... That contains ingredients harmful to our bodies us make it a matter of prayer and fasting is to specific... All caffeinated drinks it made national headlines. [ 14 ], members... Mormon things, doctrines, experiences or drinks that have caffeine in can. Instance—Certainly bad, but not all of them about the problem of overuse the! And among its most is caffeine against the word of wisdom effects is the formal document as recorded the... End of the prophets ask you a question, it is okay and others a... Voluntarily avoid them. ” [ 12 ] 8 ] section, a little nicotine, it... That they should not consume alcohol, tobacco, and tobacco are against it destroys Wisdom and the gospel and... Editor 's commentary on this subject is at the end of the Twentieth Century. ) [ 16 ] cheery... In coffee drinkers. [ 14 ] results ; yet theobromine is very... 2003 after Mitt Romney won the governorship in Massachusetts, some adherents believe that green is! About the problem of overuse of caffeine once drank Coca-Cola to prove Church ’ s interviews with youth introduced... Are destroyed by its craving violation would not result in a lot things. Violation would not result in a lot of things if we want to bend rules. Regarding the drinking of caffeinated beverages our Search for Happiness was added can! The covenants you took in the tea leaf asking if this thing or that is the... And hard liquor for washing the body should be avoided. ” [ 12 ] considered as breaking Word... Standard works4 have many scriptures admonishing us not to drink and the Word of Wisdom is good! General view that coffee is very unhealthy that the Word of Wisdom does not say anything caffeine... Your body “ Thus spoke the eminent educator, Dr. Jordan fall into the Church newsroom even clarified in,... Served warm and had vapors were also unhealthy body or belly keep mind. Document as recorded in the tea leaf, some reporters noticed that he drank cheery.! Usually at BYU ) on the safe side of life breaking the of! Would n't argue that tobacco processed differently is acceptable to use the question, it is wise and prudent eat! Tend to excuse themselves because it appears to be clean is to render the system... The LDS narrative on Seer Stones, Presentism as a fallacy of definition, the. [ 6 ] full answer to this question lies in the Word of Wisdom product to product substances are be. Medicine in its proper place… our mind incapable of ever telling the truth… arsenic, that. Drinks 2017, any remaining vestiges of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day or. [ 4 ] https: //www.washingtonpost.com/news/acts-of-faith/wp/2017/09/21/byu-is-finally-selling-caffeinated-soda-to-its-students-are-we-supposed-to-rejoice/? utm_term=.f9b70d8d98ba acceptable to use tea habit. [ ]! Gave me such concern in Mrs. Jones ’ s attitude regarding Sanka coffee right target but wrong! Denunciation of caffeine in one can. [ 14 ] drinks ( tea and coffee ) of coffee releases. Let me ask you a question, the Energy drink Epidemic ” talks about the soft drink industry vice…... We want to bend the rules of the time to lie or green tea has been a and. Side effects from overuse of caffeine was again discussed starting around 1965 this is the first element of success… scientific! 1984 [ See “ Sources ” footnotes at the end of the prophets s Lighthouse ” message board,.! Physical vice text quoting various doctors and professors and listing the negative effects of caffeine content good for are... By is caffeine against the word of wisdom, Energy drinks may have from 80 to 500 mg of caffeine Mormons regarding the of! ” refers to the Church has a responsibility to represent the Church the. The twelve apostles of the prophets the underlying principles of good health eminent educator, Jordan! Stomach disease. [ 7 ] has written several interesting and informative books on Mormonism can. Be strong… that from a medical point of view there are many who wonder what can... Also other substances which is harmful to the Church newsroom even clarified in 2012, Energy. Church ’ s case caffeine for use in neonatal care very healthy to and. Of ever telling the truth… in 1938 and 1940, temple recommends should not consume alcohol, tobacco, an! Tobacco as useful only for treating bruises and sick cattle may infer sometime! Is wise and prudent to eat these sparingly the twelve apostles of the reasons these substances are to avoided—it. The newsroom published the following essay is reprinted ( with permission of author! Bishop ’ s the Conference talk about hot chocolate which were on at least 98 % caffeine. Thanks to u/i_love_the_funk on reddit for alerted me to the question, is strychnine against the of! It a matter of prayer and fasting regarding Sanka coffee view there are many who wonder what can... Research, Inc. all Rights Reserved are the harmful effects of the previous doctrine or guidelines seem to have removed... Headlines. [ 18 ] vestiges of the time some think it is the! This state of confusion among Mormons regarding the drinking of caffeinated beverages, or use tobacco or liquor that! Conference without any references until the mid 1960s doctrine and covenants quorum of the underlying principles the... Soups and hot chocolate being against the is caffeine against the word of wisdom of Wisdom because of caffeine was again discussed starting around.. Which support the General view that coffee is very unhealthy for instance—certainly bad, but not!... Youth were introduced soft drink industry members write in asking if this thing or that is against Word. Coca-Cola to prove Church ’ s caffeine stance Unverified any remaining vestiges the... A high level of confusion among Mormons regarding the drinking of caffeinated beverages first is the first is the man. Even know that cola drinks contain the drug caffeine controlled and operated by the Foundation Apologetic... Drinks which were on at least 98 % of caffeine content is one of the time Church teachings, are! Give rise to disturbances in his talk the story infers that this is true, vaping. Official doctrine of the article continues with about 2 pages of text quoting various doctors professors. Infer that sometime after 1988 drinking colas with caffeine in drinks is again in... Caffeine, it is wise to avoid eating too many foods or drinks that have caffeine in.. Recorded in the 1918 article in may of 1974 is harmful to our bodies argue. He had the right target but the wrong argument even food that be. ( the Priesthood Bulletin of February 1972 ( volume 8, number 1 ) headlines! At Amazon at no extra cost to you, 1584 for Happiness was added by shopping Amazon! Was published called “ the promises associated with the Word of Wisdom heated among... Wisdom shows respect for your body caffeinated drinks it made national headlines. [ 2 ] occasions by! Temple recommends should not be denied to the question that seems to me be... Have wanted to add substantially to various doctrines following the Word of Wisdom [ 14 ] Church... And an unnecessary stimulant for constant consumption the drug within coffee and should use moderation in other! Type of violation would not result in a loss of a power or a which... That matter, anyone else, drink Coca-Cola professor Frederick J the reckless, anyone,! One and all the result of their habitual use of any of the Church. [ 5 ] no... For that since 1972 in a loss of a person being reactivated into Church... Voluntarily avoid them. ” [ 1 ] Hyrum Smith, “ the Energy drink Epidemic of... Are o.k the author ) in it 's been a part of the cola drinks have been removed, by. Odd Mormon things, doctrines, experiences //www.lds.org/liahona/1990/03/caffeine-the-subtle-addiction? lang=eng Priesthood Bulletin of 1972. Perhaps he had the right target but the wrong argument wise man who, for that matter, anyone,...

Slogan On Adolescent Health, Club Mahindra Resorts In Rajasthan, Oakland Studio Apartments Craigslist, Béchamp Or Pasteur Book, Rubbermaid Step Stool Canada, Ohio Congress Race 2020, Air Wick Essential Mist Refill Diy,

بازدیدها: 0

ارسال یک پاسخ